I always wanted to hear them do Waiting For An Alibi or Still In Love With You by Thin Lizzy.
Righteous Path by DBT would also rule, even as a Craig solo thing. Also, Round Eye Blues by Marah.
I know this would be divisive but the whole “togetherness” of the shows could lend them to doing what I imagine would be a rioutous version of Rock n Roll Star/What’s The Story Morning Glory by Oasis.
Staying on the Britpop theme defo a second shout for Pulp - maybe Do You Remember The First Time?
Guns of Brixton by The Clash would be cool, especially the Shea Stadium version, got a sort of Entitlement Crew/I Hope This Whole Thing Didn’t Frighten You vibe.
Improbable but as this is fantasy land...
The Highwayman - Jimmy Webb Desperados Under The Eaves - Warren Zevon A Pair Of Brown Eyes - The Pogues 1952 Vincent Black Lightning - Richard Thompson Hey Jack Kerouac - 10,000 Maniacs Way Out West - Big Star King Harvest Has Surely Come - The Band